Planning Walkthrough

Roth Conversion Analysis

Compare converting traditional retirement accounts to Roth. See year-by-year tax impact, break-even timelines, and whether converting makes sense at your marginal rate.

001
Overview

What is a Roth Conversion?

A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional IRA or 401(k) into a Roth IRA. You pay income tax on the converted amount now, but all future growth and withdrawals are tax-free. The core question: is paying tax today worth the tax-free growth later?

The answer depends on your current tax bracket vs. your expected retirement bracket, the time horizon for growth, and whether you have cash outside the account to cover the conversion tax.

002
When to Convert

When Conversions Make Sense

Lower current bracket than retirement

If you're in a temporarily low bracket (career change, sabbatical, early retirement before Social Security kicks in), converting fills up cheap tax space now instead of paying higher rates later.

Long time horizon

The further out your withdrawals, the more time tax-free growth has to compound. Converting at 40 for retirement at 65 has 25 years of tax-free growth. Converting at 60 has only 5.

Large traditional balances facing RMDs

Required Minimum Distributions at 73 force taxable withdrawals from traditional accounts. Converting some balance to Roth before RMDs start reduces future forced distributions and the tax bill that comes with them.

003
Step by Step

Using the Roth Conversion Tool

1. Navigate to the Tool

Go to Intelligence → Planning → Roth Conversion. If you have linked brokerage accounts, your traditional IRA balance auto-populates.

2. Enter Your Details

Fill in your current traditional balance, the amount you want to convert, your filing status, expected retirement income, and expected return/inflation rates.

  • Balance auto-populates from linked accounts when available
  • Conversion amount can be partial — you don't have to convert everything at once
  • State tax is included if your state has income tax

3. Read the Results

The analysis shows a year-by-year comparison of “Convert” vs. “Keep Traditional.”

  • Tax cost now: The immediate tax hit from converting
  • Break-even year: When tax-free Roth growth overcomes the upfront cost
  • Lifetime savings: Projected tax difference over the full time horizon
  • Recommendation: Based on marginal rate comparison with tiebreakers
004
Pro Tips

Pro Tips

  • Partial conversions: Convert just enough to fill your current bracket. Converting $50K at 22% is better than converting $200K and pushing yourself into the 37% bracket.
  • Pay tax from outside the account: If you pay the conversion tax from a separate cash account, the full converted amount grows tax-free. Paying from the IRA itself reduces the amount that benefits from Roth treatment.
  • Backdoor Roth: If your income is too high for direct Roth contributions, you can contribute to a traditional IRA (non-deductible) and immediately convert. Rikdom's conversion analysis helps model the tax impact of this approach.

Not tax advice. Roth conversion decisions involve complex tax considerations including state tax, Medicare surcharges, and estate planning. This tool provides estimates to inform your thinking — consult a tax professional before converting.

Ready to analyze your conversion?

See whether converting makes sense at your current tax rate.